Which Spay is Best?

Recently I have had a number of inquiries from veterinarians (and clients) about the type of laparoscopic spay I perform.  In general, there are 2 accepted techniques for performing a "spay":  ovariohysterectomy (OVH) and ovariectomy (OVE).  In an OVH both ovaries as well as the uterus are removed.  By comparison, only the ovaries are removed during an OVE.  The question is:  which technique is better and why perform one over the other?  The answer tends to stem from which technique a veterinarian was taught during their education.  Generally speaking, veterinary colleges in North America have traditionally taught OVH, while colleges in Europe teach OVE.  In recent years a decent amount of research has been done trying to determine if one technique has any advantages over the other.  In short, both techniques seem to be equivalent from a medical standpoint.  Comparisons of pain scores and recovery times showed no statistically significant difference between OVH and OVE using open (or traditional) technique.  Laparoscopic spays show a very significant decrease in pain scores and recovery times when compared to traditional open surgery.  However, when OVH and OVE were both performed laparoscopically they were deemed to be equivalent.  With respect to future disease (mammary and uterine disease specifically), there was also no difference detected between the two procedures.  In other words, there is no increased risk of mammary cancer, uterine cancer, or uterine infection if only the ovaries are removed.  This makes sense because the ovaries are responsible for hormone production (primarily) and they are removed in both procedures.  Conversely, I have been asked if I perform "tube tying" or a procedure where I remove only a piece of the ovarian horns and leave the ovaries in place (to prevent pregnancy only).  I have not found any research suggesting this is a reasonable approach, and would have concerns with respect to future disease because the ovaries would still be present and producing hormone.

 

Bottom Line:  Both OVH and OVE are excellent techniques for spaying dogs and cats, and the technique chosen is based on the individual surgeons experience and comfort level.  There is no appreciable difference between the two procedures with respect to effectiveness, pain levels, or recovery time.  Personally I tend to perform laparoscopic OVH because I went to veterinary college in Canada, but have performed laparoscopic OVE if a client or veterinarian requests that procedure.

Recent Posts

Endoscopic view of a large, yellow gallstone lodged in a bile duct.
March 11, 2026
In their never ending quest to amaze pet owners and veterinarians, dogs (and sometimes cats) are always demonstrating how many things they consider "edible". While food products such as bones and corn cobs can be understood, less tempting items such as underpants, toys, stuffed animals, shoes and jewelry tend to make us scratch our heads. Most of these items will make their way down the esophagus into the stomach, and occasionally will pass through their digestive system without any major problems. However, quite often these items will become lodged somewhere and require treatment to be removed (eg: endoscopy to pull it out of the stomach or general surgery if further into the small intestine). On rare occasions a foreign object will become lodged in the esophagus and cause the pet great discomfort. Over the past while I have been asked to remove a few esophageal foreign bodies and these are never pleasant or easy to do. Objects that become lodged in the esophagus are typically larger and more firm in nature, making it harder for the pet to swallow down to the stomach. Once the object becomes stuck it can be difficult to dislodge and swift treatment is the best chance for preventing more serious secondary trauma. In particular, animals with esophageal foreign bodies are at a risk of pressure ulcerations forming in the esophagus (where the foreign material is tightly wedged). The esophagus is not able to distend like a stomach would and pressure sores (ulcers) can start to form fairly quickly. Should the foreign material be successfully removed, the esophagus begins to repair itself and scar tissue can form. If a large amount of scar tissue forms in an area there is a risk of stricture (shrinking down or narrowing of the opening in the esophagus). In extreme cases these strictures can cause the esophagus to become so narrow that food cannot get through. When this happens the process for opening that narrowed spot back up can be time consuming, uncomfortable for the pet, and expensive. In many cases, signs of an esophageal foreign body can be difficulty swallowing, repeated swallowing motions despite not currently eating anything, drooling, regurgitation when trying to eat, and even difficulty breathing if the object is putting pressure on the trachea (airway). BOTTOM LINE: If you think your pet has an object stuck in their throat, don't wait! The sooner you can get to a veterinarian to investigate the better. Case #1: 5 year old small breed dog that was eating a dental chew and swallowed a large piece that became lodged in the esophagus. She was not experiencing any respiratory issues and was stable, so the esophagoscopy was performed later that day. The foreign object was removed leaving a mild to moderate amount of inflammation to the tissue (seen as small red depressions on the lower left image. This little girl made a full recovery. Case #2: 10 year old small breed dog with history of regurgitation for a number of days prior to presentation to his veterinarian. Radiographs showed a large amount of foreign material in the esophagus and esophagoscopy was performed to attempt to remove the obstruction. During an extremely difficult procedure we removed multiple pieces of a small plastic toy combined with a large amount of hair. The esophagus was extremely ulcerated and we were concerned about a secondary stricture formation. Despite aggressive therapy a severe stricture did form and ultimately humane euthanasia was elected. While unfortunate, this serves to demonstrate the importance of recognizing a problem and treating it as quickly as possible.
Endoscopic view of a deep red organ, possibly the liver, with a silver surgical tool at the bottom.
March 11, 2026
At some point or another the chances are that your veterinarian has recommended running "wellness" bloodwork on your pet during a visit. While many people appreciate the benefit of wellness testing, there is still some confusion as to what it is and why we (as veterinarians) recommend it. Quite often, the question we'r
Endoscopic view inside the esophagus, showing a dark, round opening at the center surrounded by pink tissue.
March 11, 2026
It's happened to all of us - we're in the middle of a surgery and our technician tells us that the patient is regurgitating. While we continue to operate, our techs quickly clean out the mouth and double check to ensure the endotracheal cuff is snug. Now what? There are a variety of ways to address an obvious regurgita